Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Archive for September, 2019

Full Frame vs. APSc for Travel

Over the summer my wife and I took a few weeks and went to Europe. We did a lot of traveling around in private cars, airplanes, boats, public transit, tour buses, the whole travel experience. I was a bit torn about the camera situation. Although my wife and I do a great deal of domestic travel plus a little Canada here and there, we don’t do the big 8 time zone deal much. As a matter of fact my wife hadn’t been back to her home country (Scotland) in over 30 years and I had never been to the UK myself. So I had every intent to get lots of pictures and I wanted the best photos possible.

As many of you know, I have a full frame EOS-R with a gazillion EF lenses and and another pile of vintage lenses I can adapt to it. I also have my trusty APS/c Canon M5 and a full suite of native glass plus a bunch of adapted lenses as well. I also wrote a review recently of the Canon G7X Mark II with its 1 inch sensor. In a perfect world where I hire a ‘caddy’ to carry my camera bag, I take the EOS-R with all of my EF L series lenses and adaptable glass. That world doesn’t exist for me however. The EOS-R was only manageable if I took maybe two lenses. Which two? Why only two? We walked several miles a day and on one day in London we logged over 9 miles, ON FOOT! We did 1.6 miles while at the Tower of London alone. I’m not schlepping 30 pounds of gear in crowded environment for miles on foot! That would literally suck the fun out of our trip.

The EOS-R and her beautiful 24x36mm sensor makes gorgeous images with a high level of dynamic range (for a Canon at least) with excellent opportunity for post work if needed. But some of you that follow this blog and my low-budget YouTube videos know just how much camera gear I can stuff into a tiny little camera bag with the EOS M5. I had to decide on lots of lenses or lots of sensor. Now before I go on, Sony E mount lenses are much smaller than either RF mount lenses or EF lenses. So Sony full frame users would not have as big a struggle with this as I did. But even the A7 series cameras are quite a bit bigger than the A6000 series or the EOS M cameras.

For me the decision was actually easy. M5 and G7X Mk II. The G7X Mk II was the camera I took when we were out at a pub or just visiting with relatives. The rest of our adventures were photographed with the M5. I have a small Tenba camera bag I have owned since the 1980s and it is only large enough to hold 3 12oz soda cans, plus a small front pocket. That’s it. Inside that tiny bag I carried the following equipment:

  • EOS M5 body with EF-M 32/1.4
  • EF-M 11-22mm IS
  • EF-M 18-55mm IS
  • EF-M 55-200 IS
  • Samyang 8mm fisheye EF-M
  • Canon Speedlite 90EX
  • 3 extra camera batteries
  • 2 extra memory cards
  • Selfie stick
  • mini-tripod

All the foreground gear fit into the bag shown (hand in frame for scale)

Yes! All of that in a bag that would otherwise hold 3 12oz soda cans. The camera charger was kept in my suitcase. The whole system weighed about 7 lbs. I will make the case again for a small MFT or APS/c camera for traveling. It was a joy not having to carry a big heavy bag. I was also well equipped to make a wide variety of images with fish-eye all the way to 200mm which on that camera is a 320mm equivalent. This could be replicated with a Sony A6000 series system as well. But if I had used an A7 Mk II I would only have fit 2-3 lenses instead of 5! With my EOS-R that bag would not have worked at all really unless I had brought a bunch of small manual focus rangefinder lenses in M mount or if I owned Canon’s all in one RF 24-240mm IS.

I was delighted with the versatility and the quality of the images I was able to bring home. We found ourselves in a number of tricky situations requiring either a very wide lens or some serious tele reach. I had it all in that tiny little bag.

Europe tends to be a bit crowded especially in the cities. It was rather useful to use that little Samyang fish-eye. I used that lens ALLOT. At f/5.6 I could hyper focal that 8mm to get everything from 2 feet to infinity sharp. At times I would simply hold the camera over my head using the flip down screen and take a picture. That technique proved very useful in several situations where I would not have otherwise captured a usable image. It also proved to be quite fun in other situations. I took well over a thousand images on the trip that spanned a couple of weeks. I had about 300-400 good keepers and a couple of dozen shots that I really like. The M5 performed very well, we were in Iceland, Scotland, and England, so it rained fairly often. The M5 is not officially weather sealed but it seemed content enough in a damp environment. Although I was cautious, I didn’t let a little rain get in the way of my picture making. After all I live in Western Washington, it is known to rain here on occasion 😉

In short I feel that for traveling where photography is secondary to the overall experience, take a micro four thirds or APS/c system, preferably the latter. Had I taken my EOS-R and a suite of my L series lenses, many of my images would have been superior, some of them much superior. I would, however certainly have left the EOS-R behind for a large portion of my trip and relied too much on the G7X Mk II, so overall I would have inferior images; a few great shots and a bunch of mediocre shots. I have some images I made on the trip below but I also want to show some possible alternative light weight options for travel with different systems that might also fit in my tiny Tenba bag; take a look below:

The M5/M6 simple approach

  • Canon EOS M5 with EF-M 18-150 IS
  • Canon EF-M 11-22 IS
  • extra batteries, selfie stick or minipod, extra mem card

The Sony A6000/6100/6300/6500/6600 approach

  • Sony A6000 series body with 18-135mm OR high quality Zeiss 16-70mm
  • Sony E-APS/c 10-18mm
  • extra batteries, mem cards, minipod

The Sony A7 approach

  • Sony A7 series with E 24-240mm OR high quality 24-105/4
  • Voightlander M mount 12mm/5.6 with adapter

EOS R approach

  • EOS R or RP (RP is smaller) with Canon RF 24-240mm IS or high quality RF 24-105 L
  • Voightlander M mount 12mm/5.6 with adapter
  • Extra batteries / mem cards

The Canon SLR approach

  • Canon Rebel SL3 with EF-S 18-200 IS
  • Canon EF-S 10-18mm IS
  • extra batteries/mem cards

The Nikon SLR approach

  • Nikon D5500 with DX 18-300mm VR
  • Nikon DX 10-20mm VR or high quality 10-24mm ED
  • Optional Nikon DX 10.5mm fish-eye
  • Extra batteries / mem cards

Bare in mind that the so called “super zooms” like the 24-240 or 18-300, 18-135, 18-150 etc. tend to be inferior lenses whereby your are trading image quality for the convenience of such a range. But the most important thing to remember is the best camera/lens combo in the world is the one you have with you! If your camera is so bulky and inconvenient that you decide to leave it in your hotel room, then it sucks.

Below are a few images from the trip, you’ll find that I got a fair bit of use from that 8mm fish-eye lens. Also you will see the only real disadvantage to the smaller APS/c sensor was in the super low light shots like the second shot of St. Mary Abbotts Church at the bottom of the page. I had to push that shadow detail up and it got pretty noisy 😦

St Mary Abbotts Church, Kensington, London M5 with EF-M 11-22 IS at 11mm

From the Tour Bus, London. M5 with Samyang 8mm

The ruins at St. Andrews, Scotland M5 with 11-22 IS at 22mm

Performer at the Tower of London, M5 with EF-M 55-200 IS at 200mm

The Royal Mile, Edinburgh, Scotland M5 with Samyang 8mm

Wifey poses with piper on the Royal Mile, Edinburgh, Scotland M5 with 32/1.4 at f1.4

Hand held selfie, Castlegate, Aberdeen Scotland M5 with EF-M 11-22mm IS at 11mm

Buchannon Street on the Style Mile, Glasgow, Scotland Canon G7X mk II at 9mm (24mm)

Red Phone Booths, Edinburgh Castle, Scotland M5 with Samyang 8mm

Edinburgh International Festival, Royal Mile M5 with Samyang 8mm

The Hub, Royal Mile Edinburgh, Scotland M5 with Samyang 8mm

On the Tube (subway) in London. M5 with Samyang 8mm

The Tower Bridge along the River Thames to Canary Wharf from the 33rd floor of the Shard. M5 with EF-M 18-55 IS at 35mm

Dunnottar Castle, Scotland M5 with EF-M 11-22 IS at 17mm

Young couple selfies in ancient St. John’s chapel at the Tower London, M5 with Samyang 8mm

Traffic Circle near Trafalgar Square, London M5 with Samyang 8mm

The Doctor is Out, Glasgow Scotland Canon G7X mk II at 9mm (24mm)

St. Mary Abbotts Church (very dark inside) Kensington, London M5 with Samyang 8mm

Advertisements

Read Full Post »

Urban Living in the 'Couv'

America's Vancouver is Rising

Liberty or Death

An Intellectual Conservative View

SUPER MOVIE MANIAC

Latest facts, news and predictions for every Super Marvel movie nerd. Are you nerd enough? Click the Menu tab at the side for more!

The WordPress.com Blog

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

Idrona

This WordPress.com site is the cat’s pajamas

The Tech Column

One guys opinion on the tech that's all around us.

SW Washington Land

Opportunities in residential, recreational, and commercial land

'Couv' Commercial Properties

Retail, Industrial and Office properties in Vancouver, USA

New Homes

Clark County Washington: Rod Sager, Realtor® Vancouver, USA

PhotoFair Camera Shows

Modern and Vintage Cameras and Photo Gear

Heidy's Online Wonderland

MMORPGs, Entertainment, Random Musings and Stuff

Comics A-Go-Go! Comics, Movies, Music, News & More!

Irresponsible blogging at its best

blurppy

Purveyor of pop culture...burdened with glorious purpose...

Holodeck3

"Fate protects fools, little children, and ships named Enterprise."

Bob Mayer

Write on the River

After Dark Gaming

the red eye gamer

The One-Man Trekker

And our trek has only just begun...

Funk's House of Geekery

Movies, Comics, Books, Games and Other Things Geeks Love

digitaldtour

A photographic journey through the Southern California car culture

Star Trek Online

Beaming in from The 'Couv'

The Scorpion and the Frog

Fiction - Poetry - Photos

Journey Into Awesome

A critical look at comics and culture

The Evergreen Times

More than twenty years of commentary and it just keeps coming

The 'Couv' Life

Musings of life in Vancouver, Washington U.S.A.

clouddomains

Just another WordPress.com site

Custom Skins by Jodi Tripp

Don't let your phone go Naked!

Portland Flooring Blog

Your flooring source for carpet, hardwood, tile and green surfaces in Portland Oregon

Broachs's Blog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

Donna's Ink Well

The source of expressed thought

Voice of the People

We, the People seem to agree on most everything...

The Lipstick Liberal

the liberal who still enjoys bein' lady-like.

fredperkins

A fine WordPress.com site

searching4serenitydotorg

A topnotch WordPress.com site

Washington State Short Sales

A fine WordPress.com site

Clark County Real Estate Guide

An Insider's Guide To Real Estate, Mortgages and The Heartbeat Of Clark County, WA

annetterlane

Just another WordPress.com site

thefairybookmother

A topnotch WordPress.com site

clarkcountyhousetalk

SW Washington real estate talk

Kay Hunt 4 Homes

Kay's Food 4 Thought

Clark County Weather Blog

cameras, lenses, and photography

'Couv' Camera

cameras, lenses, and photography

The WordPress.com Blog

The latest news on WordPress.com and the WordPress community.

%d bloggers like this: